FAQs

What's the difference between your chocolate boxes? The assorted boxes are the best place to start if you're not sure what you like—they come with a mix of milk and dark pieces, soft centers, nuts, and caramels. If you already know you're a Bordeaux person or a Scotchmallow person, you can get those in dedicated boxes or by the piece. The Nuts & Chews box leans into texture; the Dark Chocolate box is for people who find milk chocolate too sweet.

What's a Bordeaux? It's the one with the little chocolate sprinkles on top—brown sugar and buttercream covered in milk or dark chocolate. It's been the signature piece for a long time, and for good reason.

What's a Scotchmallow? Honey marshmallow and caramel, covered in dark chocolate. It's the one people either love immediately or need a second bite to understand. There is no third option.

Are your products made with preservatives? No. That's why they have a shelf life and why we recommend eating them within a few weeks of arrival. Store them somewhere cool—60 to 70 degrees is ideal—and keep them away from direct sunlight. If your house runs warm, the refrigerator works for longer storage, but bring them to room temperature before eating so the texture comes back.

Why does my chocolate have a white film on it? That's bloom—cocoa butter or sugar rising to the surface because of temperature changes during shipping. It's harmless and safe to eat. The texture might be slightly different, but it's not spoiled. If it bothers you, the guarantee covers it.

Do you ship in the summer? Yes, with insulation and cold packs. Heat-sensitive orders ship expedited by default from April through October. Hard candy, lollipops, and brittle can ship ground without insulation because they don't melt the same way.

Can I ship to multiple addresses? Yes. Each shipment needs to meet the $80 threshold separately to qualify for free standard shipping. If you're sending gifts to five people, each box is its own shipment.

What if I need it by a specific date? Check the shipping calendar at checkout—it shows available delivery dates for your zip code and the items in your cart. During holidays, order-by dates are posted on the site. If you're cutting it close, expedited or overnight is the safer bet.

Are the lollipops really made in their own kitchen? Yes. "The Lollypop Guild" is a dedicated facility just for lollipops and Little Pops. It's not a marketing story—it's a separate building.

Something's wrong with my order. What do I do? Use the contact form. Tell us the order number and what happened. If it arrived melted, crushed, or just wasn't right, say so. We'll work it out—refund or replacement—without making you fight for it.